Il y a 2 heures
Barry Bonds, the Home Run King, is a name that stands out in baseball history. But despite his legendary status, he’s been absent from MLB The Show 26—and the series as a whole—for years. The reasons behind his absence are not just about the game itself; they involve a mix of business, licensing, and baseball politics. Let’s break down why the player who hit 762 home runs remains “The Unseen Legacy” in the game.
1. The Licensing Wall: Opting Out of the MLBPA
The heart of the issue lies in Bonds' decision back in 2003. Most players, both active and retired, agree to a collective licensing agreement with the MLB Players Association (MLBPA). This agreement allows game developers, like San Diego Studio (SDS), to use player likenesses and names for a set fee. However, Bonds chose a different path.
Bonds' Independence:
Barry Bonds became the first player to opt out of this collective agreement. By doing so, he retained full control over his name, image, and likeness (NIL). Instead of allowing the MLBPA to handle licensing on his behalf, Bonds chose to negotiate his rights independently. This means SDS can’t just purchase the MLB roster rights from the MLBPA and get Bonds as part of the package. They’d have to negotiate a separate, private contract with him—a complex and expensive process.
2. The Financial Disconnect
Negotiating with someone like Barry Bonds is no small task. He knows his value, and his price tag reflects that.
High Price Tag:
Bonds is one of the most famous players in MLB history, and his individual licensing fee would reflect his status. For SDS, the cost of acquiring his rights may simply be too high compared to the potential return. With hundreds of other legends like Ken Griffey Jr. and Babe Ruth already in the game, the studio has to weigh whether including Bonds would make financial sense.
A "Precedent" Issue:
There’s also the issue of setting a precedent. If SDS agrees to pay Bonds a large fee, it could open the door for other top-tier legends like Alex Rodriguez or Roger Clemens to demand similar payouts. This would likely put a strain on the game’s development budget, making it less likely that Bonds will return unless a deal can be struck.
3. The Hall of Fame & PR "Politics"
While there is no official rule, there is a strong correlation between a player’s standing with Major League Baseball and their inclusion in MLB The Show. The players that get included in the game are often Hall of Famers or at least in good standing with the league. Bonds, however, has been kept out of the Hall of Fame due to his ties to performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs).
The Steroid Era Cloud:
Bonds’ association with PEDs has been a major factor in keeping him out of the Hall of Fame. Many people see him as a controversial figure from the Steroid Era, and this has led both MLB and SDS to maintain a "clean" image when it comes to the game’s roster. As a result, some of the most prominent figures from that era, including Bonds, remain absent from the game, regardless of their on-field accomplishments.
Image Control:
MLB and SDS tend to prioritize the “good guy” storylines, aiming for a clean, positive portrayal of the sport’s history. Bonds, being a controversial figure, doesn’t fit that mold, which further limits his chances of appearing in the game.
4. The Legacy of the "Placeholder"
Despite his absence, Bonds is far from forgotten in the world of baseball video games. In previous versions of MLB The Show, SDS created a "placeholder" for Bonds in the form of a fictional player.
Reggie Stocker:
In older MLB The Show games, a left-handed outfielder named Reggie Stocker, who wore number 25 (the same as Bonds), appeared in the game. He had maxed-out stats that mirrored Bonds' abilities, making it clear to fans that this was an unofficial stand-in for the real thing.
Jon Dowd:
Bonds’ absence also led to the creation of "Jon Dowd" in the MVP Baseball series. Dowd was a fictional player with Bonds’ exact playing style and stats. While it was a bit of a workaround, it showed just how much fans wanted to see Bonds in the game.
User-Created Content:
In MLB The Show 26, fans have taken matters into their own hands by creating their own versions of Bonds. Using the game’s Vault feature, players can download and use custom-made versions of Bonds, complete with his real face, batting stance, and equipment. It’s a testament to the lasting impact of Bonds’ legacy, even if he’s not officially in the game.
Barry Bonds’ absence from MLB The Show 26 is a result of a complicated mix of licensing issues, financial considerations, and baseball politics. Unless SDS can strike a deal with Bonds or he re-enters the MLBPA’s collective licensing agreement, it’s unlikely we’ll see him as an official part of the game’s roster. For now, fans can enjoy custom-made versions of Bonds, but the Home Run King remains a "created player" in the world of MLB The Show.
1. The Licensing Wall: Opting Out of the MLBPA
The heart of the issue lies in Bonds' decision back in 2003. Most players, both active and retired, agree to a collective licensing agreement with the MLB Players Association (MLBPA). This agreement allows game developers, like San Diego Studio (SDS), to use player likenesses and names for a set fee. However, Bonds chose a different path.
Bonds' Independence:
Barry Bonds became the first player to opt out of this collective agreement. By doing so, he retained full control over his name, image, and likeness (NIL). Instead of allowing the MLBPA to handle licensing on his behalf, Bonds chose to negotiate his rights independently. This means SDS can’t just purchase the MLB roster rights from the MLBPA and get Bonds as part of the package. They’d have to negotiate a separate, private contract with him—a complex and expensive process.
2. The Financial Disconnect
Negotiating with someone like Barry Bonds is no small task. He knows his value, and his price tag reflects that.
High Price Tag:
Bonds is one of the most famous players in MLB history, and his individual licensing fee would reflect his status. For SDS, the cost of acquiring his rights may simply be too high compared to the potential return. With hundreds of other legends like Ken Griffey Jr. and Babe Ruth already in the game, the studio has to weigh whether including Bonds would make financial sense.
A "Precedent" Issue:
There’s also the issue of setting a precedent. If SDS agrees to pay Bonds a large fee, it could open the door for other top-tier legends like Alex Rodriguez or Roger Clemens to demand similar payouts. This would likely put a strain on the game’s development budget, making it less likely that Bonds will return unless a deal can be struck.
3. The Hall of Fame & PR "Politics"
While there is no official rule, there is a strong correlation between a player’s standing with Major League Baseball and their inclusion in MLB The Show. The players that get included in the game are often Hall of Famers or at least in good standing with the league. Bonds, however, has been kept out of the Hall of Fame due to his ties to performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs).
The Steroid Era Cloud:
Bonds’ association with PEDs has been a major factor in keeping him out of the Hall of Fame. Many people see him as a controversial figure from the Steroid Era, and this has led both MLB and SDS to maintain a "clean" image when it comes to the game’s roster. As a result, some of the most prominent figures from that era, including Bonds, remain absent from the game, regardless of their on-field accomplishments.
Image Control:
MLB and SDS tend to prioritize the “good guy” storylines, aiming for a clean, positive portrayal of the sport’s history. Bonds, being a controversial figure, doesn’t fit that mold, which further limits his chances of appearing in the game.
4. The Legacy of the "Placeholder"
Despite his absence, Bonds is far from forgotten in the world of baseball video games. In previous versions of MLB The Show, SDS created a "placeholder" for Bonds in the form of a fictional player.
Reggie Stocker:
In older MLB The Show games, a left-handed outfielder named Reggie Stocker, who wore number 25 (the same as Bonds), appeared in the game. He had maxed-out stats that mirrored Bonds' abilities, making it clear to fans that this was an unofficial stand-in for the real thing.
Jon Dowd:
Bonds’ absence also led to the creation of "Jon Dowd" in the MVP Baseball series. Dowd was a fictional player with Bonds’ exact playing style and stats. While it was a bit of a workaround, it showed just how much fans wanted to see Bonds in the game.
User-Created Content:
In MLB The Show 26, fans have taken matters into their own hands by creating their own versions of Bonds. Using the game’s Vault feature, players can download and use custom-made versions of Bonds, complete with his real face, batting stance, and equipment. It’s a testament to the lasting impact of Bonds’ legacy, even if he’s not officially in the game.
Barry Bonds’ absence from MLB The Show 26 is a result of a complicated mix of licensing issues, financial considerations, and baseball politics. Unless SDS can strike a deal with Bonds or he re-enters the MLBPA’s collective licensing agreement, it’s unlikely we’ll see him as an official part of the game’s roster. For now, fans can enjoy custom-made versions of Bonds, but the Home Run King remains a "created player" in the world of MLB The Show.
![[-]](https://smartphoton.ch/forum/images/collapse.png "[-]")
